Tracking the tools that decentralize the media. tools process ideas resources eventsav

unmediated

 

March 08, 2005

Richard Harper dismantles the vision of merging multiple communication devices to form meta devices that bundle disjunct streams of revenue, but neglect the relationship between media and platform.

"For those of us in research, however, particularly those of us who do "user research", the idea of convergence is quixotic. It is a distraction from explorations of things that might be more salient. This is not to say that we doubt whether people in the future will sometimes want technology to combine different functions, it is just that we think that these combinations might need to be thought through more carefully than is typically the case. It is very rare indeed that users want everything combined in a single device. It is much more often the case that the reverse holds true: users want things separated and simpler, not combined and more complex."

Originally posted by hypergenesb from del.icio.us/hypergenesb, remediated by yatta on Mar 8, 2005 at 05:56 PM


Comments

that is very true. But the most upseting is that most technologists say they want convergence , just because they don't understand how simple people want things to be. It seems a Holy Grail of some sort . A funny thing about it is that the highest boss of big companies like Nokia and others go on speaking about convergent devices and nevertheless their teams succed in donig sometimes simple tools.

Posted by: michon at March 9, 2005 01:33 PM

Is their any reason why this Holy Grail device can't be a simple tool? All it takes is a little imagination to envision a device - say it looks like a Sony Ericsson P910 - that hooks up wirelessly to whatever keyboard/screen/mouse combination you happen to be near (at home or at work); a device that either contains your data or acts as a portal to data that is stored elsewhere; one that, when you're out and about, also serves as PDA, mobile phone, camera, and entertainment device. Each of these functions could be activated and used via a simple, intuitive interface.

I think if something like this existed and were pretty low in cost, lots of people would want one.

Posted by: Doug Thacker at March 10, 2005 06:13 PM

Excerpt:
Post a comment









Remember personal info?