Tracking the tools that decentralize the media. tools process ideas resources eventsav

unmediated

 

January 04, 2005

The five stages of media death
Clay Shirky responds to the article complaining about Wikipedia by one of its ex-founders with a point-by-point refutation and the observation that Wikipedia's detractors are going through the Kubler-Ross stages of death:
It s been fascinating to watch the Kubler-Ross stages of people committed to Wikipedia s failure: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance. Denial was simple; people who didn t think it was possible simply dis-believed. But the numbers kept going up. Then they got angry, perhaps most famously in the likening of the Wikipedia to a public toilet by a former editor for Encyclopedia Brittanica. Sanger s post marks the bargaining phase; OK, fine, the Wikipedia is interesting, but whatever we do, lets definitely make sure that we change it into something else rather than letting the current experiment run unchecked.

Next up will be a glum realization that there is nothing that can stop people from contributing to the Wikipedia if they want to, or to stop people from using it if they think it s useful. Freedom s funny like that.

Finally, acceptance will come about when people realize that head-to-head comparions with things like Brittanica are as stupid as comparing horseful and horseless carriages the automobile was a different kind of thing from a surrey. Likewise, though the Wikipedia took the -pedia suffix to make the project comprehensible, it is valuable as a site of argumentation and as a near-real-time reference, functions a traditional encyclopedia isn t even capable of. (Where, for example, is Brittanica s reference to the Indian Ocean tsunami?)


(Continued at BuzzMachine)
Posted by yatta at 11:25 PM