Tracking the tools that decentralize the media. tools process ideas resources eventsav

unmediated

 

November 09, 2004

RSS enclosures are a fish with legs
Though humans came from fish, we are not fish with legs. Audio/video syndication comes from RSS, but it is not RSS with enclosures.

For any type of microcontent -- reviews, FOAF, playlists -- the ability to syndicate comes from data which can easily migrate from one place to another and a few generic fields needed for periodically updated content. Webjay's XSPF playlists are convertible to Atom because of a few minor additions:
  1. The playlist header contains an atom:modified element.
  2. Each playlist entry contains an atom:id element, an atom:modified element, and an atom:issued element.
It is shareability that defines syndication, not personal journals. XSPF is a playlist format designed for shareability. RSS is a personal journal format designed for shareability. RSS with enclosures is a personal journal with ancillary audio or video.

RSS 2.0 allows a text entry field to be associated with a feed; to support comments on individual entries, it allows a comment URL to be included in a feed. These have absolutely nothing to do with audio and video. They are like fins on a squirrel. At the same time, audio and video need data not available in RSS, like the name of the drummer or URLs for versions in different codecs. A fish with legs may be able to walk, but to leave the water it has to stop being a fish.


Posted by yatta at 11:47 PM